I generally will not have a lot to say, but, from time to time I will add something to this blog as the mood or conditions warrant.
October 10, 2023
As an historian you hear all kinds of statements concerning the
American Civil War that are simply ridiculous. I have heard people mix
up pirates and Civil War soldiers wearing Zouave uniforms…which was made
all the more funny because pirates didn’t have any uniforms. Many people
believe that all the soldiers in the Civil War were quite young when, in
fact, the average age of the soldier was higher during the Civil War
than during the Vietnam War. We hear people explain to their children
that the common shelter ("pup") tent was small “because people were
shorter back then. The soldiers could walk inside the tent standing up.”
Yes...I really did actually overhear a parent explaining this to their
child in all seriousness.
Just as people do not understand these smaller historical facts, most
people simply do not understand the major concept of civil war any
better than did the people of both north and south on the eve of the
Civil War. It was commonly thought then that there would be one battle
and that would decide the war. Maybe some people would be killed, but
they would be some strangers. Instead they saw a four-year-long journey
through Hell that laid waste to the countryside, and led to the deaths
of seven hundred thousand American men – more than have been killed in
all other conflicts that the U.S. has been involved in, from the
Revolution through to the current time. This does not take into account
the civilian deaths from the resulting starvation, murder, disease, etc.
A generation of young men were killed, traumatizing their families, etc.
The economic impact of losing that number of workers is astounding. The
war left its mark on every aspect of life in the country and some areas
of the country still foster ill-will to their former enemies even seven
or generations later. Everyone knew someone lost in the war. It became
very personal. It was no longer an abstract concept fought by strangers
somewhere else.
So, today, when I hear someone bandying about the notion that “we need a
new Civil War,” I know that the individual is uneducated in what civil
war actually results in or what it means. A civil war is not the
solution to the fact that people are taken in by “yellow Journalism” –
yes, it is still going strong one hundred and twenty-five years after
the Spanish American War – and believe false stories. A civil war is not
a solution to the fact that people of the two major parties simply can’t
deal with one another because of their egos. I suppose this is why the
largest political “party” by far are now independents who have abandoned
both main parties due to their inability to work together. Civil war
means going against the Constitution, and that is not the way to fix
things.
If those foolish members of society such as television pundit Greg
Gutfeld or politician Sarah Palin call for a civil war, they probably do
it to get another fifteen minutes of fame. I mean, they really could not
be that uneducated, or quite frankly, that stupid. Civil war is not a
subject to spread for momentary personal gain except by the most
egotistical or uneducated. This is not something to take likely as every
time it is suggested it makes the idea more legitimate. Let me explain
what a civil war actually means.
People seem to have this odd feeling of nostalgia for the Civil War
period. I find it fascinating too. I have studied it for years. I have
read diaries that show the horrors and the miracles. I can stand on a
Civil War battlefield and see the action in my mind. However I certainly
don’t advocate for civil war as a means of working out our issues
(simply accurate telling of the truth via reputable media is a better
approach). Of course…that nostalgia many people have today for the war
was not held by those that actually lived through it. The survivors
formed close bonds to those they served with, but often could not sleep
at night from the horrors they had witnessed. We now know about PTSD.
Back then, they had it too, but they just didn't know what it was or how
to deal with it. The veterans came home changed men, many dealing with
things they could actually deal with or even talk about. They said that
they hoped that no one would ever have to go through "that" again. Those
that did not survive were those seven hundred thousand empty chairs
around the family tables. Those families certainly would not recommend
this route.
The American Civil War was fought for a variety of reasons, all much
more deep than simply believing false television news from people who
make their ratings and money from stirring up discontent that we see
today. There were constitutional issues such as whether the states or
the federal government had the right to make certain laws (“states
rights”). States rights showed up in issues as diverse as
taxation and slavery, etc. The right of a state to secede from the
country was the actual major Constitutional issue and was the true issue
over which the war was fought. Though we don't like to admit it now, the
horrible institution of slavery itself did not become an issue of its
own until later in the war. The basis on the war began was the right to
secede, not slavery. In short, we have no major constitutional issues
such as these today. We have stupidity. Stupidity is not a reason for
civil war.
The major issues today are…hmm… seems to be if the election system
works. No evidence has yet been found to say that the election system
was unfair or did not work. There are a lot of claims, but not one has
been upheld in court as there was simply no evidence. That is not a
partisan statement. It is a statement of fact. People have to realize
that Facebook is not a news source and is no more reliable than your
crazy Uncle Bernie (because, quite frankly, the news on Facebook comes
from everyone's crazy Uncle Bernie. That is how it functions). Is the
false claims something to kill your neighbor over? No. If you don’t like
the outcome of the election, then perhaps your side – and the other side
– should work to find common ground as has been done for over two
hundred years in this country, not suggest killing each other.
I remember the days when the at Speaker of the House Thomas P ("Tip) O'Neill and President Ronald Reagan would fight for their partys' ideals during working hours, and then get together as friends later in the evening. What an amazing concept!
Remember the famous slogan "only you can prevent forest fires?" Well, only sanity can prevent civil wars. Our leaders are showing very little of that lately, so we must react to their insanity with sanity, and quit repeating the suggestion that civil wars are good.
July 29, 2023
TURBIFY may be gone, but they had one last shot, and blew it. Turbify had been sending me emails stating that my account would renew on July 16. As the migration to Bluehost had just been done, I needed to wait 48 hours to cancel my account. The 48 hours would end on July 15...so I cancelled on July 15. Turbify sent me an email confirming that I cancelled on July 15. Then I received my credit card bill and found that they had charged me for another year! I contacted Turbify with a copy of their email concerning the renewal date and a copy of the email confirming the cancellation was completed a day before the renewal date. Turbify claimed that in spite of their repeated emails stating that the account would renew on July 16, it actually renewed on June 16! I explained again that they repeatedly notified me that July 16 was the renewal date and explain that I had no need to go in and check my account since they were sending me notifications with the renewal date. I referred them to their emails! Of course, the customer service person could not resolve this, but had to send it to a higher level. A few days later, I got another email stating that the issue had to be kicked up even one more level. Lastly, and most surprisingly, Turbify finally refunded the amount.
But really...Turbify is that messed up that they cannot even send out a correct renewal date email? Wow. It appears that their business side is as badly messed up as is their technical side.
Again, my review of Turbify is to run from them. They are technically
incompetent, and cannot handle basic business issues!
Now, with the migration completed to a reliable host, I can begin
focusing more on content and less on hours of technical work. In time -
possibly two years - I can get the readership back to where it was
before Turbify reared its ugly head in my life.
July 15,
2023
TURBIFY IS GONE!! At least from this website. After fighting with TURBIFY since February, I gave up. TURBIFY could not fix the issues that it created on the website with their faulty data migration when Turbify forced the website to be migrated from Yahoo Website Services. After copious research I opted to move the website to a new host - Bluehost. The site has been migrated. Interestingly, in talking to the person heading the migration, I showed him the error messages I have been receiving...the same error messages I have shown to Turbify for months...and he said "Oh, it looks like they have screwed up your permalinks." That would explain the issues I have been seeing. Unfortunately, this is something that Bluehost cannot fix...they cannot undo Turbify's mistakes!
So, in short, Turbify put me back several years in growth. but Turbify is gone, and I can move ahead.
If you ever have the thought of looking for a webhost, don't consider
Turbify. In fact, run from Turbify.
March 3,
2023
So…its
been a bit rough. How do I put this simply. TURBIFY DESTROYED MY
WEBSITE!
This website has been with Yahoo Small business for years. That has not
been pretty as Yahoo Small Business was changed to Yahoo Small Business
/ AaBaco and now Turbitfy. In the first changeover, they migrated my
data and thoroughly messed it up. The migration lost all of the page
descriptions and keywords, and scrambled some of the .html coding. The
website survived. Starting about 3 years ago I made an effort to step in
and correct all of the crap that resolved from the last migration after
simply not dealing with it for many years. It took three years!!!
Now, Yahoo Small Business has become Turbify and migrated data again,
and required me to change my “name servers” through my domain registrar.
The results have been a nightmare from which I am not sure the site can
recover. Since February 16, the date of the Turbify data migration, the
site has lost two-thirds of its visitors. Apparently people out there
are not able to find the site. I know that if I use the on-site search
engine that is found on the site’s main page, 95% of the results return
a “404 webpage not found” error. This has only occurred since Turbify
migrated the data. Simultaneous to that my ftp site was no longer able
to access the website, something I was eventually able to resolve.
In the last week have spent nearly 9 hours on calls and chats with
Turbify and Network Solutions (the domain registrar) trying to resolve
the issues. Turbify has been no help. In fact, once, during the
conversation with their help desk, they killed off the entire site.
What appears to be the situation now Is that out on the web there appear
to be links that point to my webpages, but the files indexed by Turbify
do not have the .htm or .html suffix on the address, so links cannot
find them apparently. I don’t understand why the index with pages
without .htm and .html exist since the pages always had the suffixes and
still do. Now, I have gotten an email from Google indicating that I have
pages with 403 and 404 errors…which will impact the site's ranking...and
I cannot do anthing about it on my end. I tried re-uploading my entire
site. I created, uploaded and submitted a new sitemap...but nothing
worked. Again, thanks Turbify.
I have no idea how to repair this damage since it really has nothing to
do with me or the website I have uploaded. It has to do with something
Turdify did (did I write TURDify…I surely meant Turbify). Years of work
are going down the tubes thanks to them.
The most recent chats with Turbify have indicated that an enhancement
will be coming out that will address my issue. I asked directly if other
people are experiencing the same issue, and the support person
reluctantly indicated that I am not the only one. The person could not
tell me when the enhancement (read as correction) will be issue. I tried
to get them to narrow it down to the next day, next week, next month or
2034...and they would not narrow it down. My case has been escalated and
I should hear from them next week. Of course, the last time they said
they would get back to me, they called me at 4:00 AM to say that my
website was working fine...but there as really no improvement and we
were just woken up in the middle of the night.
Thank you Turbify on a job horribly done. I can only assume that the
name Turbify comes from the word “turbidity” which means “the quality of
being cloudy, opaque, or thick with suspended matter.” Sewage and puss
from an infected wound have high turbidity. Much like Turbify.
DON'T USE TURBIFY!!!
Update #1: Turbify had stated that they had their software engineers working on the issue, and gave me a case number. I was told I would hear from them in 3 to 5 working days. That would have been last week. As of that time, the case number does not even show up in my "open cases" list. I guess it should tell me something that they have an "open case" list on the dashboard. Anyhow, they also have a place where I can see the errors noted on the website. My error list IS 18 PAGES LONG...and that was only in the last day!
Honestly...I have seen slight improvement, but the site is still
floating in 404 and 443 errors (404 is "page not found," and 443 means
that Google is not being permitted to index the page. Supposedly this
website issue has been given a priority...right.
Update #2: SO....we are now about 5 weeks into this problem.
Turbify has failed in all respects. Some pages are still getting 404
errors (in spite of their saying it was corrected). My error log on
Turbify continuously has error list comprising 20 pages, and that
generally only covers the last 4 hours! I have called Turbify and was
told that a case had been opened and I would hear back in 3-5 days. I
didn't hear back. I opened up a written case. I uploaded the error log
as part of the case. Turbify responded three days later asking for a
screen shot. I added several. FIVE DAYS later, Turbify again responded
and AGAIN asked for a screen shot. Is that customer service? Turbify has
made no effort to address the errors. At this point I have little hope
of Turbify solving this problem. They obviously take have to log so many
customer responses an hour. This is obviously a big problem so they give
me a meaningless answer and move on to the next complaint.
Update #3: March 25 - The issues continue. Turbify has YET
AGAIN asked for the same information on the written case. Before they
made the latest request and the written case seemed stalled, I opened
another case through the Turbify customer service chat feature. This
time they looked at the error data and "escalated the case" to a higher
level. Of course, I have been told this before several times, and only
once heard back, and that silly response was that the website was fine!
Only today I have also been notified that the written case has been
"escalated to the back end team." In both cases I have been told I will
hear back in 3-5 business days...so yet another week and then maybe I
will hear from the...er..."backside team." I rather think of the Turbify
customer support collectively as the "backside team," if you know what I
mean. In the mean time, the graph below shows the extent of the issue.
This is a chart of the organic searches that the website receives. The
big drop corresponds to the day Turbify migrated the data of this
website on February 16th. Apparently, people performing organic searches
are getting 404 or 443 errors, stating that the website cannot be found
about 50% of the time.
Update 4 - April 7, 2023 - Turbify's terrible customer service continues. Turbify finally contacted me to tell me that they could not replicate the errors I have reported and asked me to supply more info. on these reputed errors. I pointed them to their own site. Turbify uses CPanel which provides their users with info. on their websites. CPanel has a section simply entitled "errors" ...so this is data Turbify is supplying to me. I uploaded a .pdf of the errors that their own site is reporting. The .pdf included errors that occurred only within the last four hours and was 19 pages long!! I have provided them with this information before, and they have access to it directly themselves. I have forced their staff to look at the errors (and that was difficult to do), only then would they admit that there was a problem. But now, their backside people...er... Back end people...cannot find this data. Simply unbelievable!! Turbify customer service is the worst I have ever experienced. We are approaching two months and they have yet to solve the problem...in fact, they cannot even find the problem event hough their own data is showing the errors! Avoid Turbify (formerly Yahoo Small Business) at all costs.
Update 5 - April 29, 2023 - Well...Turbify's "back end" (their
term...but appropriate) people seem to have failed. They closed
out the case without solving anything. Of course, they did not contact
me to tell me. They did not ask any questions. I forced the case to be
reopened (or, actually opened yet another case). The situation has not
improved. Search engines are apparently being denied access to the
website consistently. I have asked about a refund since the site is not
working properly because of their errors...I got crickets. I guess they
can't afford it! I am not surprised as I look at Turbify's ratings.
Anyhow I am being forced to move the website to a different host. I have
never done that before, and have to determine if that involves migrating
the bad data (the stuff Turbify messed up) or uploading new. Its a mess.
Really...I encourage everyone to avoid Turbify. Its been a horrible
experience. Don't let Turbify happen to you! Remember...Friends don't
let friend Turbify.
November
18, 2022
I
was asked is the collective memory of the Civil War more harmful than
helpful?
Now there is a good question with sooo many aspects.
First we need to look at what was the collective memory is, how it has
changed over time, and its impacts over time.
The initial collective memory was that perpetuated and institutionalized
by the veterans of the Civil War themselves. The veterans – who were
obviously the survivors of the war – were lucky enough to come home. In
many cases they had developed a deep comradery with those with whom they
had served. Most military units were local – formed in one location
rather than recruited over a large area – so many of the men had a
strong shared experience having served in the same locations and under
the same circumstances. They formed organizations such as the G.A.R.
(Grand Armies of the Republic) in the north and the UCV (United
Confederate Veterans) in the south. These organizations kept the
comradery alive through monthly meetings, events, and reunions. They
honored their heroes. The organizations also aided those who were sick
with small monetary stipends.
So what did this comradery create as a collective memory? The veterans
knew the reasons for which they had enlisted, which had some individual
variation, of course. However, for the most part, in the north the
reason for enlistment was the preservation of the Union. In the south,
the reason was states’ rights and to repel what was considered to be an
invasion. This is quite different from what is commonly said today.
Today it is often erroneously said that the war was over slavery. During
the war and in its immediate aftermath the major point for both sides
was the right of individual states to secede from the United States.
This - secession - was the states’ rights issue that resulted in the
war. The veterans knew this. They disagreed on whether the right of
secession existed but the collective memory was that this was the reason
for the war. Slavery was one of several ongoing states’ right issues
that had been argued about for years, but neither side was going to war
over slavery itself. In the north, the Emancipation Proclamation (which
did not actually free any slaves in areas controlled by the north at the
time) would not be issued until the war had been ongoing for nearly two
years. It was issued not simply because it was the right thing to do. It
was issued to keep European nations – namely Great Britain – from
entering the war on the side of the south. At the time there were
concerns expressed by many in the north that the Emancipation
Proclamation would impact recruiting as it could be construed as
beginning to change the focus of the war away from the preservation of
the Union. Many northern men made it clear that they were fighting to
preserve the union, not over slavery, as sad as that may be to admit
today. In the south, the men were now fighting to protect their homeland
which had been invaded. There are recorded interviews out there with
aging Confederate veterans during which they were asked if they were
fighting for slavery. They indicated that they really had not thought of
that. They were fighting to protect their homes. Remember, the common
southerner was not a slave owner. They could not afford it regardless of
their belief for or against slavery.
It is notable the that veterans’ organizations which were the strongest
advocates of the collective memory were made up of the survivors.
Obviously, those who died in the war were not part of the organizations,
nor were the families of the dead. Therefore, the glorious actions and
their memories experienced by the survivors were perpetuated over the
feelings of utter loss of the families of the dead. Over time,
thankfully, it is also notable that an individual’s memory often begins
to drop some of the horrors and remember the better parts (though many
men dealt with PTSD then, but no one knew what it actually was). It was
these memories – those of comradery, friendships formed in battle and
glory, not those of death – that became the new collective memory over
time.
This collective memory was handed down to the veterans’ children. They
grew up knowing their fathers' comrades, attending the reunions with
their fathers, etc. In fact, as the veterans began to pass into history
themselves, the children formed organizations – Such as SUV (Sons of
Union Veterans) and the SCV (Sons of Confederate Veterans) to continue
their fathers’ memories. Of course, they had no memories of the actual
tragedies of the deaths of comrades in the field, only the memories of
the comradeship their fathers experienced and childhood memories of
stories told by old men, polished with years of re-telling.
These collective memories of the second generation had a strong impact
on the next conflict in which the U.S. was involved – the Spanish
American War. When war was declared, there was a mad rush to join the
volunteer regiments. In fact so many regiments were being formed by the
states that federal government stated that it would accept no more. The
states responded by enlarging the accepted regiments by one-quarter –
from nine companies to twelve companies. Still, there was great
competition to get into one of these regiments. Very few underage men
made it into the army (contrary to common opinion) since those who were
not legally eligible were recognized and removed and legally eligible
men took their place. One of the reasons for this outpouring was the
collective memory of the lifelong comradeship experienced by these mens’
fathers in the Civil War. They sought the glory and comradery that their
fathers had extolled as their collective memory of the war. Removed by a
generation, the collective memory of the horrors of losses in the field
was forgotten and was not in the collective memory of the second
generation.
Sadly, the rush to join the military during the war led to many deaths.
The majority of the regiments formed were simply not needed and never
left the U.S. Instead, they were brought together into training camps
unprepared for the vast numbers. Disease spread quite literally like
wild fire. The majority of the men lost in the war by a factor of ten
were to disease, and the majority of those in camps in the United
States. In short, men died partly because of an inaccurate collective
memory
So what is the collective memory today? What is its impact? Today the
collective memory of the war is quite different today. Children today
are taught that the Civil War was fought to end slavery. This is a noble
thought, but simply untrue. Still, as this is what is taught to the
recent generations, it has become their collective memory viewed through
the lens of more recent battles for equality and civil rights. This
collective memory makes the Civil War a racial war with the forces
arrayed against each other being that of anti-slavery versus white
supremacy. General Grant is looked upon as good. General Lee is looked
upon as bad...but Grant owned a slave. Technically, Lee did not (his
wife did). This collective memory is harmful as it casts the history in
an untruthful light with people citing the new collective memory as a
reason for their views today and as a justification to take a militant
stance. Taking a militant stance on an inaccurate view of history is
always dangerous. One only need to look at the grossly erroneous
collective memory created by the Nazis concerning the role of Jewish
people in history to see the dangers of false history and
falsely-created collective memories. The Civil War is looked at as being
glorious. War is never glorious. People die. They are forgotten. Their
motives and beliefs are forgotten and construed by later generations for
their own desires.
The collective memory that is missing is that the war was a sad and
bloody mess. More Americans died in the Civil War than all other wars
the U.S. has been involved in taken together. The Civil War - or any war
- is not something to emulate, or mindlessly advocate. It is deadly
business. The men who saw their friends lose their lives to sucking
chest wounds, bleed to death from lost limbs, or die from dysentery
understood this. The Civil War was not a war over slavery. It was not
glorious. Saying it was plays into those promoting false and dangerous
ideas today. The Civil War was and is horrible to contemplate. Anything
based on false history can only damage and mislead.
March 11,
2021
We still intend to add an “Educator’s Corner” to provide some materials that educators may find useful when teaching about the war. We have seen some of the items being used and they have been a bit lacking. Maybe we can help improve on the resources available.
June 17, 2020:
Work is still ongoing on a article on how the U.S. funded the Spanish American War. I had next planned to write on the military intelligence and diplomatic negotiation aspect of the war, specifically on how the U.S. worked to keep the Spanish government from threatening Dewey's toehold in the Philippines. This portion of the war centered on Egypt and the Suez Canal. That said, in view of the state of affairs in the country, I think I may put that on hold briefly to write on the men of color who received the Medal of Honor for their actions during the war. If memory serves, six men of color received the Medal of Honor for service during the war, four of them in one action.May 23, 2020:
In the past month, we have updated almost every page of the website (about 1231 pages,...whew!), looking for broken links, and updating titles and descriptions. We found that that when Yahoo migrated all of its websites to a third party, that migration wiped out the page titles and description. This is one of the reasons why the website dropped a bit in visibility. We also updated meta words to help the search engines locate articles. During the updates we added some google analytics coding so we can see what pages get more hits, which will help us to plan a bit. Lastly, we added the coding to allow ads to show. Since ad placement is handled through artificial intelliegnce through Google, We cannot control the size or the number too well. We did set a control that only allows the ads to be at 50% of the volume the ad company would prefer. We may cut that back.April 24, 2020:
Just to let you know, ads are on the way. I am not thrilled about that, but it has to be. Ad placement will be determined using smart technology from Google. I will not be choosing the locations...so hopefully they will be OK. I did block vignette ads, which are the full page ads.April 20, 2020:
I made a command decision. This website costs money to operate between
URl registration, hosting fees, software, etc. Also it takes a lot of
time. Sooo...if I am going to continue to do this, I have to break down
and add some ads. I alwys resisted ads, but, after 24 years, it is time.
I will will to make them no too annoying. The ads will be from Google
Adsense, and the ads shown will be based on your searh history
elsewhere. That means that the ads will be for something you had some
sort of interest in. Sorry about this!
April 16, 2020:
The news has had a bit of Spanish American War irony to it about which I felt the need to commemorate!
The coronavirus, covid-19, has been raging around the world. It is not at all surprising to read that the virus has struck the military. The most notable case is that of the crew of the aircraft carrier, THEODORE ROOSEVELT. The ship’s crew members began to show symptoms of the virus. In the crowded decks of this five thousand man floating city, there is no real way to stem the spread. Widespread quarantine and isolation is not practical, and the crew is still needed to allow the ship to function to fulfill its defensive role.
Apparently, the rapid pace of the situation outpaced the ability of the command structure to respond to the ship’s needs. The commanding officer, Brett E. Crozier sent a letter via email to other naval personnel in the Pacific fleet, as well as the entities such as the acting secretary of the navy, trying to enlist their aid in combatting the situation. Reportedly Crozier knew that the unclassified letter, passing outside of the naval command structure, could end his career. The letter, and the growing plight of the crew was shared beyond the original addressees, eventually made it into the San Francisco Chronicle. The navy brass and the administration were embarrassed by the situation and how it was exposed.
The letter had the desired impact. The shipped was docked, and the crew was partially removed and quarantined. By this time, hundreds of the crew had the virus. Though the crew is generally young and quite physically fit, some of the crewmen were hit hard, and so far, with the situation ongoing, one has died. Crozier himself now has the virus. As Crozier expected he was relieved of command, but cheered heavily by his devoted crewmen. The acting secretary of the navy travelled to the ship and in a speech castigated Crozier for being “stupid” and “naïve” for not believing that the text of his letter would not get out. In an ironic twist, the acting secretary was apparently too stupid and naïve to realize that his own comments would get out…and when it did, he was forced to resign!
The whole situation took me back to an important event during the Spanish American War. In Cuba, after the naval Battle of Santiago and the battle of the San Juan ridge (“San Juan Hill”…but it was actually a series of ridges), the fighting basically came to an end. The troops in Cuba now faced a new enemy – disease! Yellow fever had been a great fear, and it began to infect the troops. As time went on, many companies were reduced to a handful of men able to stand for duty, and the number of men impacted rose into the thousands. Major General Shafter’s efforts only brought suggestions from the administration in Washington that the troops be moved into the mountains in an effort to allay the illness, a pointless suggestion given the actual terrain and the positions that the troops needed to occupy. The administration was loathe to bring the men home for fear of spreading the disease in the U.S. and exposing the true condition of the troops themselves.
The officers of various regiments knew something had to be done, but they knew that trying anything different than making requests through the chain of command would bring repercussions. The officers requested a meeting with Shafter, but knew that the situation had to be addressed in writing and would likely have to move outside of the normal chain of command. The officers knew that whoever would write such a letter likely see their career ended.
With generals unwilling to risk their careers, a colonel of volunteers (not a career soldier) took up the task. He explained the situation, made suggestions about where the troops could be placed in the U.S. The colonel signed the letter. The other officers signed off on the letter, basically attesting to it, but not taking responsibility. The letter became known as the "round robin" letter. When the colonel handed the letter to Major General Shafter, Shafter did not accept it, but instead directed it to a reporter, something that was rather expected, if not planned. The letter soon appeared in newspapers across the country, and the deplorable condition of the troops could not be denied. The administration was forced to bring the troops back to the U.S., and replace them with new troops, mistakenly thought to be immune to yellow fever. The troops came home to a camp on Long Island, New York, which was named “Camp Wickoff.”
The move possibly saved thousands of lives, but the colonel had embarrassed the administration in Washington, especially Secretary of War Alger. Since the colonel was not a career officer and was soon being mustered out, there was not much retribution that could be exacted – except one thing. The colonel had deservedly been nominated for the Medal of Honor. The secretary of war refused to authorize the medal.
That colonel, by the way, was Colonel Theodore Roosevelt, future president and the namesake of the aircraft carrier under Crozier’s command. The two men are joined not only by the ship’s name, but by their actions to save their men.
Incidentally, Roosevelt eventually
received his Medal of Honor but not until 2001, about eighty-five years
after the old colonel’s death.
February, 2020:
This website started back in 1996, two years before the centennial
of the Spanish American War. That was twenty-four years ago. We're now
actually looking toward the 125th anniverary of the war. It is still a
generally overlooked and forgotten event in the United States, but we
will continue to try to educate the public about the war's importance
Anyhow, from 1996 until about 2010 - 2011 I managed to keep up fairly well with all of the data submitted. People geneerally do not realize the amount of time it takes to add things to the website and maintain is organization. The National Spanish American War Veterans' Gravesite Recording Project is particularly time consuming, but of imporantance in that the data has not ben brought together anywhere else. Because of the amount of unique information that people pull out of their basements and attics and send in, the Library of Congress chose this site as one of the first to be backed up as part of its "Minerva Project."
Of course, in about 2008 the Great Recession started. By 2011, the Recession was wreaking havoc with my business, and also Yahoo made a series of changes internally, and I suddenly found myself with no time to work on the website, let alone overcome the obstacles presented by Yahoo's changes. I continued to collect the data that came in.
Recently I was forced to delve back into the website when a reader reported that a website that this website had linked to had been hacked and was quite foul. I had to overcome various technical issues and regain site access to correct that situation. With this accomplished I was able to begin making other various updates. Now, with the coronavirus shutdown, and a reduction in my work hours to a normal 40 hour week, I have had some additional time to begin adding data collected over the past few years.
Though I will not be able to do as much as I used to do, I will
continue working to add and update the site.
Thanks for your patience!